Battle of the Century, Heero Yuy Vs. Kira Yamato

[Hellmaster Inu]

Who do you think would win in an all out Gundam fight? Heero Yuy in the Wing Zero, having mastered the Zero System or Kira Yamato in the Freedom, in SEED Mode. It's obvious the Wing Zero and Freedom are probably two of the most powerful Gundams in the history of Gundam.

Note: I felt like making this poll for the fun of it. Don't say I'm being stupid.

[seba_boi]

Heero cuz Kira's a pansy...

[MagicianCamille]

Heero Yuy in Wing Zero, the Twin Buster Rifle can destroy a colony, Freedom can't move and shoot all of it's cannons at once I believe, so if they both fires their best weapons(neither of them can move and use them at the same time), Heero's Twin Buster Rifle beam would clear through Kira's shots, and wipe the Freedom out. While Freedom's shots don't really have the power to damage the over-powered Wing Zero.

Unless Freedom CAN move and fire those cannons at the same time, in which case: Heero.

[Demonboy]

hmm, if Wing Zero scores a direct hit on Freedom then obviously Freedom is KO'd. But what happens if Wing Zero misses 3 times (or 6 times if heero split them) ? Its TBR would have no power left to be of any use. Freedom's guns on the other hand would last a long time considering Freedom's energy source. I think according to the TV series it would take A LOT of Freedom's cannons to actually damage Wing Zero, but according to Endless Waltz I think it wouldn't take too much damage.
After that I think it would just end with close range duelling with beam sabers, by that time I can't really imagine who will win because its fairly even at that point.

P.S you should add a 3rd option (something like "both dies" or "draw" or something)

[MagicianCamille]

Ugh no, I hate the "draw" option in these kind of polls, it's so indecisive, eventually one of them would be triumphant, and the idea of them both killing eachother is just...lame.

[CrossboneGundam]

Heero, the lesser of two evils.

[Mazinkaiser]

I always thought that the 3 shot rule only applied to the Wing Gundam, I heard somewhere that the Wing Zero had an infinite amount of shots. If I'm wrong, and the Wing Zero only has 3 shots, then I'd have to say that Kira'd win, otherwise Heero'd win.

[Sharp-kun]

I'm pretty sure the twin buster rifle was fired more than 3 times in one battle, in dual fire mode.

[Omega Supreme]

Actually I say Heero, the greater of two evils. Kira maybe annoying, he is atleast a humman being with emotions. Remember they both pull the "I don't want to kill anymore" card.

[Westlo]

The 3 shot limit is at full power

Anyway Kira will win because Kazuma beat Ryuhou in ep 26 of Scryed

I would say Kira in SEED mode, don't forget SEED mode is something like being in a Super Saiya-jin or Super Mode form. Zero System don't even come close in power.

When we compare suits well both are incredibly overpowered and nothing seems able to destroy them. Wing Zero Gundam maybe able to destroy a colony but Freedom can shoot 5 guns at the same time. So I guess they're even in that department.

[Musashi9X]

Well comparing pilots, Heero and ZERO system is probably a fair match for Kira with his SEED Factor, though on raw piloting ability alone I would give it to Heero, so advantage Heero.
Comparing machines, Freedom is formidable, but Wing Gundam Zero is practically godlike. It basically comes down to speed and construction. I'd give the speed advantage to Wing Zero, simply because if Tallgeese has heart exploding acceleration, lord only knows what Wing Zero is like, and Kira never had any problems with Freedom. And then Wing Zero has the wonderalloy Gundanium, with a heat tolerance so high it can shrug off barrages of weak beam rifle fire and use a shield made of it that can block beam saber hits. Freedom just has Phase Shift armor, so one well placed beam saber or TBR shot and that's pretty much all she wrote for Kira. Advantage Wing Gundam Zero.
Basically the only way I could see Kira winning was if Heero just stood there and let Kira wail on him for a good 5 minutes at least.

Originally Posted by Hellmaster Inu

It's obvious the Wing Zero and Freedom are probably two of the most powerful Gundams in the history of Gundam.

And either V2, God, or Turn A could probably just fart and beat both of them.

[Demonboy]

Chances are, the TBR will not be a diciding factor guys bear in mind. It is more than likely that Kira can dodge those, the same with Kira's beam cannons. (Heero rarely uses his TBR in a duel with a skilled pilot like himself, same with Kira rarely uses his cannons against another skilled pilot in a duel.)

But in general I don't really see this as a reasonable comparison in terms of technology because of the inconsistency in Wing's universe. If you watch GW:EW you will see that the Wing Zero isn't that imprevious to damage, but watch the TV series and it makes all the weapons fired on it look like pea shooters which do no harm.

Wing Zero made be made of Gundanium but it can still sustain damage from beam sabers (like in EW) which will probably be the main weapons of choice for both suits if it comes down to a duel.

[Hellmaster Inu]

Originally Posted by Musashi9X

And either V2, God, or Turn A could probably just fart and beat both of them.

I'm sure the V2 for the Freedom could. I've never seen the God or Turn A in action, so I can't respond on them. I bet the God Gundam is pretty kickass though. Soon I will own the G Gundam boxsets!

[Westlo]

Don't forget good ol Devil Gundam