Question:
Do you think the popularity of anime and manga in North America is in any way correlated to a “failure” of the domestic comic and cartoon market? It seems to me that more often than not, the reason any “consumers” switches to a different “brand” lies in the utility. Maybe the new product has better features, better design, better marketing, better affordability, etc. Placing anime and manga into the equation, it seems that the recent popularity explosion is in fact directly related to the stale state of domestic alternatives. Maybe if the domestic animation and comic industries had grown over the years, they might currently have “better” stories, style, and substance such that “jaded” consumers would not have to look to anime and manga for their entertainment instead.
Though I am not an expert, it seems quite apparent that if one looks back some 10, 20, or even 30 years at animation and comic books in North America, the themes, stories, and character varieties have more or less remained constant. While the same might be true about the Japanese counterparts as well, they did not invade foreign countries until recently, and hence are “new” genres and ideas to foreigners. I am hardly insinuating that it is a bad thing for Japanese products to be so popular in North America, nor am I trying to suggest there is anything fundamentally wrong with North American comics or animation. Rather, this is simply a brief foray into the idea of “foreign appeal” as opposed to “domestic familiarity.” Any thoughts?
(more…)